For small recruiting agencies
Spreadsheet or ATS for a small recruiting agency?
Most small agencies run hiring in a spreadsheet, and for good reasons. Here is when a sheet is enough, where it starts to cost you, and what changes with an ATS you never type into.
When a spreadsheet is enough
A sheet is free, everyone knows it, and you can shape the columns to your process. It works well when:
- one or two recruiters share a handful of open roles;
- candidates come from your own sourcing, not a steady flow of applications;
- the person who ran the interview is the only one who needs the notes.
Where it starts to break
- The same candidate sits in three tabs with three spellings of their name.
- Interview notes live in someone's notebook or a chat, not next to the candidate.
- Every update is typed by hand, so the sheet is always a few days behind.
- A CV that fits a different role is never looked at again.
- When a recruiter leaves, what they knew about their candidates leaves with them.
Side by side
| Task | Spreadsheet | Classic ATS | Neither |
|---|---|---|---|
| Adding a candidate | Type a row from the CV | Type the CV into a form | The application or CV builds the profile |
| Interview notes | Written after the call, somewhere | A free-text box | The call is filed to the candidate and scored with quotes |
| Matching to roles | In your head | Search and filters | Each applicant is scored against every open role |
| Missing details | You email and copy the answer | You email and copy the answer | Neither emails the candidate; the reply fills the profile |
| Cost to start | Free | Usually a paid seat per recruiter | Free to start, no card |
Moving off a spreadsheet without retyping it
Download the sheet as CSV or Excel and import it once. People already in Neither are matched, not duplicated. From then on, new applications, CVs, documents and interviews update the records, so nobody types them in.
What Neither doesn't do yet
- It never rejects, hires or decides on anyone. Every hiring decision stays with a person.
- No Outlook calendar, no candidate self-booking page, no careers page and no job-board posting.
- No sync with other ATS products.
Questions
Is Google Sheets good enough for recruiting?
For one or two recruiters with a few open roles, often yes. It stops working when several people share candidates, interviews pile up and nobody has time to keep the rows current.
Do I have to retype my candidates to move to an ATS?
Not in Neither. Import the CSV or Excel export of your sheet; people already there are matched, not duplicated.
What does it cost to try?
Neither's HR Free plan is $0 with no card. Recruiter is $99 a month, and Team is $249 a month for 3 recruiters.
Try it on one vacancy
Free to start, no card. Sign up with Google and paste your first vacancy.
More ways Neither saves typing
Use cases
- Interview notes written from the call
- Every applicant scored against every open role
- CVs and documents become the profile
- Interview scorecard from a job description
- Missing candidate details collected by email
- Interviews booked without the back-and-forth
For agencies choosing an ATS
- How to choose an ATS for a small agency
- Every step of hiring, and who does what
- What Neither does for recruiting agencies