Switching from a spreadsheet
Moving off a recruiting spreadsheet: a practical checklist
A recruiting spreadsheet is easy to leave and easy to lose. Its history sits in tabs, colours, comments and the inboxes around it. Four steps that keep it, whichever tool you move to.
1. Make one full copy, and write down what it means
A sheet has no export button that catches everything. Make one dated copy of the whole file and a short note next to it:
- every tab, including hidden and filtered ones, and the old copies people made;
- what the colours, status codes and abbreviations mean; a CSV keeps neither colours nor comments;
- where the CVs really are: Drive folders, inboxes, chats;
- who owns the file and who can edit it today.
2. Check about 10 records against the export
Open the copy, not the live sheet, and pick about 10 people you know well. Ten is enough to find what's missing, and few enough to do in an hour.
- a candidate you placed, with the client and the date;
- someone who applied last week;
- someone you put forward for several roles;
- someone with a CV, a cover letter and other files;
- a client contact with notes from several calls;
- a name written in Cyrillic, to check the letters survive.
For each one, compare the export with what you see on screen: contact details, CV, notes, status, dates. Write down every gap. That list is what you ask the vendor about, while you still have access.
3. Test only your 3 daily tasks, with real data
Demos show every feature. Your team will live in three. Take one real open vacancy and the real CVs for it, and try only these in the new tool for a week:
Adding a candidate
In Neither, an application or a dropped CV builds the profile, and every fact keeps its source. Nobody retypes it.
Writing up an interview
In Neither, the notetaker joins interviews on your Google Calendar in Google Meet, Zoom or Teams, files the call to the candidate, and one click scores it against the vacancy with the candidate's own words.
Finding who fits an open role
In Neither, each new applicant is scored against every open vacancy, not only the one they applied to.
If the three tasks are faster and the records stay complete without anyone typing, the rest can wait. If not, no feature list will fix it.
4. Decide what not to migrate
Moving everything moves the mess too. Agree with the team what stays behind in the archive copy:
- candidates past your data retention period, or who asked to be removed;
- duplicates: keep the most complete record of each person;
- rows with no contact details and no CV;
- colour codes nobody can explain any more;
- fields nobody has filled in for a year.
Keep the full export as a read-only archive with a named owner, so the old history is there when someone asks.
Where Neither fits, honestly
Neither is built for exactly this move: from a shared sheet to records that fill themselves. Here is where it fits:
- It fits agencies of 3–15 recruiters who want candidate records to fill themselves from applications, CVs and recorded interviews.
- It doesn't connect to or sync with other ATS products, so it won't read your old system for you.
- If you need job-board posting, a careers page or an Outlook calendar today, a larger ATS fits better.
- It never rejects, hires or decides on anyone. Every hiring decision stays with a person.
The quickest test needs no sign-up: paste one of your vacancies into the free scorecard and see whether the requirements read the way you would write them.
Questions
When is it time to move off a spreadsheet?
When several recruiters share candidates, interviews pile up and nobody has time to keep the rows current. Until then, a sheet is often enough.
Should I keep the old spreadsheet?
Yes. Keep one dated, read-only copy with a named owner as the archive, and stop editing the live one on the day you switch.
What does it cost to try Neither?
Neither's HR Free plan is $0 with no card. Recruiter is $99 a month, and Team is $249 a month for 3 recruiters.
Try it on one vacancy
Free to start, no card. Sign up with Google and paste your first vacancy.
More ways Neither saves typing
Use cases
- Interview notes written from the call
- Every applicant scored against every open role
- CVs and documents become the profile
- Interview scorecard from a job description
- Missing candidate details collected by email
- Interviews booked without the back-and-forth
For agencies choosing an ATS
- Spreadsheet or ATS for a small agency
- How to choose an ATS for a small agency
- Every step of hiring, and who does what
- What Neither does for recruiting agencies